China is fond of describing its special economic zones as a development model it can hand over. The more honest version, set out in a World Bank paper by Douglas Zhihua Zeng, is that the playbook is exportable while the outcomes are not. China started in 1980 with four zones - Shenzhen, Zhuhai and Shantou in Guangdong, then Xiamen in Fujian - as deliberate experiments in market-oriented reform of land, labour, tax and customs, then rolled the reforms out nationally once they worked. Africa has often tried to skip straight to scale, and the gap between the two approaches explains much of what has followed.
Four Zones, Not Forty
The Bank's first lesson is restraint. China piloted with a handful of zones at strategic coastal sites, proved them, then expanded into more diversified forms including high-tech parks. Many African countries, Zeng writes, "start with 10 or even 20 zones all at once, which is a recipe for failure." The discipline was institutional too: the Shenzhen SEZ Act was passed by the national congress the same month the zone launched in August 1980, giving local reforms top-level legal cover, and a land-leasing system from 1981 created a modern land market where none had existed. The point was never the fence around the land; it was the sequence - experiment, verify, then scale.
This is the first part of the article. The full article is on Cabanga Magazine, from the publishers of the regional business magazines in Africa.
Read the full article on Cabanga Magazine


